QIAN Jiayan, HUANG Zihui, YU Yang, et al. Cohort Study on Traditional Chinese Medicine and Western Medicine Comprehensive Treatment in 520 Patients with Cervical Scrofula[J]. Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine2020, 61(2): 130-135.
QIAN Jiayan, HUANG Zihui, YU Yang, et al. Cohort Study on Traditional Chinese Medicine and Western Medicine Comprehensive Treatment in 520 Patients with Cervical Scrofula[J]. Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine2020, 61(2): 130-135.DOI: 10.13288/j.11-2166/r.2020.02.010.
Cohort Study on Traditional Chinese Medicine and Western Medicine Comprehensive Treatment in 520 Patients with Cervical Scrofula
Objective To compare the clinical efficacy of different Chinese and western medicine anti-tuberculosis regimens in the treatment of cervical scrofula
and to analyze the correlation with use of surgical therapy and disease recurrence rate. Methods From October 1
2016 to July 1
2018
520 patients with cervical scrofula who received anti-tuberculosis treatment in Nanjing Hospital of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine constituted a follow-up cohort. They entered the 3 queues including western medicine anti-tuberculosis treatment combined with traditional Chinese medicine(TCM) internal treatment group(control group Ⅰ)
western medicine anti-tuberculosis treatment combined with TCM external treatment group(control group Ⅱ) and western medicine anti-tuberculosis treatment combined with TCM comprehensive treatment group(observation group). The TCM syndrome score and the maximum transverse diameter of lymphatic tuberculosis were compared after 4 weeks of treatment in each group of patients
and the selection of surgical treatment as well as recurrence were observed during the 1-year follow-up. Results A total of 449 cases were included in the analysis. After treatment
the TCM syndrome score and the maximum transverse diameter of lymph tuberculosis were reduced(P<0.05). The improvement in the control group Ⅱ was superior to that in the control group Ⅰ(P<0.01)
and the improvement in the comprehensive treatment group was significantly higher than that of the control group Ⅱ(P<0.01). According to the effective status after treatment(TCM syndrome score improving rate ≥70%) and surgical indications
139 patients chose anti-tuberculous non-surgical treatment and 381 patients chose surgical treatment. Among them
29 patients in the control group Ⅰ were included in non-surgical treatment. The control group Ⅱ included 38 patients with non-surgical treatment
and 72 patients received non-surgical treatment in the comprehensive treatment group. The lost follow-up rate was 8.85%(46/520) and the overall recurrence rate was 2.22%(10/449). The recurrence rate of non-surgical patients was 2.24%(3/134)
and the recurrence rate of surgically treated patients was 2.22%(7/315). There was no significant difference in the recurrence rate of surgically treated patients and non-surgically treated patients(P>0.05). Conclusion The combination of TCM and western medicine against tuberculosis can effectively treat cervical scrofula
and the therapeutic effect of TCM combined with anti-tuberculosis western medicine is more significant. There is no specific correlation between surgical treatment and non-surgical treatment
but the comprehensive treatment of TCM combined with anti-tuberculosis western medicine can effectively reduce the incidence of surgery in patients with cervical scrofula.
Recurrence Rate and Clinical Effect of Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease Treated with Compound Formulas for Rectifying Qi and Directing Counterflow Downward:a Meta Analysis
Longmu Jiawei Decoction (龙牡加味汤) for Moderate to Severe Atopic Dermatitis with Heat Accumulation due to Wind-damp Syndrome:A 31 Cases Observation
Effect of Qi-Boosting,Yin-Nourishing Blood-Quickening Medicinal on the Recurrence Rate of 16 Patients with Cryptogenic Organizing Pneumonia
Effect of Electro-Acupuncture at the Cleft Points and Alarm Points on Renal Colic and A Accompained Symptoms in 26 Cases
Clinical Study on Treatment with Yiqi Huayu Shengji Decoction(益气化瘀生肌方) for Chronic Erosive Gastritis Patients with Qi Deficiency and Blood Stasis Syndrome in Qinghai Area
Related Author
DANG Zhongqin
CHEN Xiaole
QIAN Peiguo
LI Songwei
LI Mengge
LUO Lei
DANG Zhibo
Chaoyi MAO
Related Institution
Henan Province Hospital of Traditional Chinese Medicine (The Second Affiliated Hospital of Henan University of Chinese Medicine)
Xiyuan Hospital, China Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences
China Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences
Center of Traditional Chinese Medicine, University of Oxford