LIU Fan, DUAN Yuting, ZHANG Xuan, et al. Reporting Quality Evaluation and Literature Analysis on Qualitative Interview Research in the Field of Traditional Chinese Medicine[J]. Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine2020, 61(6): 528-532.
LIU Fan, DUAN Yuting, ZHANG Xuan, et al. Reporting Quality Evaluation and Literature Analysis on Qualitative Interview Research in the Field of Traditional Chinese Medicine[J]. Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine2020, 61(6): 528-532.DOI: 10.13288/j.11-2166/r.2020.06.016.
Reporting Quality Evaluation and Literature Analysis on Qualitative Interview Research in the Field of Traditional Chinese Medicine
Objective To evaluate reporting quality of Chinese literature on qualitative interview research in the field of traditional Chinese medicine(TCM)
and to make suggestion for normalized report of qualitative interview research. Methods Chinese literature on qualitative interview research in the TCM field in CNKI
VIP and Wanfang was retrieved. Retrieval time was from the establishment of the databases until October 10
2019. The quality of literature reports was evaluated by using items in Consolidated Criteria for Reporting Qualitative Research(COREQ) and Standards for Reporting Qualitative Research(SRQR). Results Twenty-two literatures were included. The average reporting rates of research team and reflexivity
research design
analysis and results in the COREQ standard were 11.4%
44.2% and 48.5%
respectively. There were item 7(participants′ knowledge of the interviewer)
item 8(interviewer characteristics) and item 18(repeat interviews) with a reporting rate of 0. The average reporting rates of the title and abstract
introduction
methods
results/findings
discussion
and others in the SRQR standard were 88.7%
86.4%
55.4%
77.3%
56.9% and 40.9%
respectively. The item with a reporting rate of 0 was S20(conflicts of interest). Conclusion Qualitative research methods in the field of TCM still need further normalization. It is suggested that the COREQ and SRQR standards should be referred for design
implementation and results report in future qualitative research reports.
Qualitative Interview on Modification of WHOQOL-HIV
Evaluation and Thinking on the Report Quality of N-of-1 Randomized Controlled Trials of Traditional Chinese Medicine Published in Journals in Mainland China
Analysis on Correlation of Methodology Quality and Reporting Quality of Case-control Studies in Traditional Chinese Medicine
Evaluation on Methodological and Reporting Quality of Randomized Controlled Trials of Tuina Therapy for Childhood Diarrhea Using CONSORT and STRICTA Standards
Construction and Application of "Source-Pivot-Convergence" Pattern Identification and Treatment Model for Malignant Tumors
Related Author
HE Li-yun2
HAO Yuan-tao1
XU Delin1
KANG Jing2
CAI Nanqiao1
LI Jiansheng
ZHANG Hailong
ZHAO Hulei
Related Institution
School of Public Health,Sun Yat-sen University
China Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences
Province-Ministry co-construction Innovation Center for Chinese Medicine Prevention and Treatment of Respiratory Disease, Henan University of Chinese Medicine/Henan Key Laboratory of Respiratory Diseases Prevention and Treatment of Traditional Chinese Medicine
The First Affiliated Hospital of Henan University of Chinese Medicine
The Second School of Clinical Medicine,Guangzhou University of Chinese Medicine