GUO Qi1, TIAN Xin2, YANG Aoran3, et al. Quality Evaluation of Literature on TCM Therapy for Coronary Heart Disease[J]. Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine2012, 53(20): 1734-1736.
GUO Qi1, TIAN Xin2, YANG Aoran3, et al. Quality Evaluation of Literature on TCM Therapy for Coronary Heart Disease[J]. Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine2012, 53(20): 1734-1736.DOI: 10.13288/j.11-2166/r.2012.20.009.
Objective To observe the efficacy and analyze the problem of TCM therapy for coronary heart disease(CHD) by the quality evaluation of literature on TCM therapy for CHD.Methods The literature on TCM therapy for CHD from January 1982 to January 2012 were researched and collected in Chinese Biomedical CD
Chinese Biomedical Literature Database
Literature Database of Traditional Chinese Medicine
VIP Chinese Science and Technology Periodical Database
Chinese Journal Full-Text Database
Wanfang Database and China Medical Academic Conference Papers Database.The collecting literature was analyzed and evaluated according to evaluation criterion including method of randomization
allocation concealment
diagnostic criteria
efficacy criteria
baseline comparability
blindness
follow-up
case lost and method of statistics.Results There were 82 articles met the inclusion criteria
64 articles(78.0%) with balanced comparison between groups
8 articles(9.8%) with proper randomized controlled method
8 articles(9.8%) with proper blinded method
0 article with description in compliance testing of subjects
5 articles(6.1%) with follow-up record
2 articles(2.4%) with loss of follow-up record
58 articles(70.7%) with clear statistical methods but without posteriori statistical analysis and 72 articles(87.8%) recorded adverse reactions and safety.Conclusion TCM therapy for CHD is lack of multi-center study
with cross-mix of diagnosis criteria and efficacy assessment and low quality of the research program.