Meta Analysis on Curative Effects of Yiqi Fumai Injection( Lyophilization)( 注射用益气复脉) Combined with Conventional Western Medicine for Chronic Heart Failure
WANG Xianliang, MA Ning, HOU Yazhu, et al. Meta Analysis on Curative Effects of Yiqi Fumai Injection( Lyophilization)( 注射用益气复脉) Combined with Conventional Western Medicine for Chronic Heart Failure[J]. Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine2016, 57(5): 391-395.
WANG Xianliang, MA Ning, HOU Yazhu, et al. Meta Analysis on Curative Effects of Yiqi Fumai Injection( Lyophilization)( 注射用益气复脉) Combined with Conventional Western Medicine for Chronic Heart Failure[J]. Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine2016, 57(5): 391-395.DOI: 10.13288/j.11-2166/r.2016.05.008.
采用Cochrane协作网提供的偏倚风险评估工具对纳入研究进行方法学质量评价。采用Rev Man 5.2.6对患者临床综合疗效、心功能分级、左室射血分数、左室舒张末内径、氨基末端前脑钠尿肽进行Meta分析。结果共纳入18篇文献
1939例患者
文献质量偏低。Meta分析结果显示
加用注射用益气复脉(冻干)治疗慢性心力衰竭可以提高患者临床综合疗效[OR=3.63
95%CI(2.22
5.93)
P<0.001]
改善心功能[OR=1.98
95%CI(1.48
2.65)
P<0.001]
增加左室射血分数[WMD=4.35
95%CI(3.32
5.38)
P<0.001]
降低左室舒张末内径[WMD=-2.59
95%CI(-4.97
-0.21)
P<0.03]
降低氨基末端前脑钠尿肽[WMD=-298.41
95%CI(-453.86
-142.97)
P=0.0002]。结论在纳入研究的范畴内
注射用益气复脉(冻干)联合西医常规治疗慢性心力衰竭可进一步改善患者症状和心功能
提高临床疗效。
Abstract
Objective To systematically evaluate clinical effects and safety of Yiqi Fumai Injection( lyophilization) combined with conventional western medicine for chronic heart failure. Methods China journal full-text database
Chinese technical journal full-text database
Wanfang database
Chinese biomedical literature database
EMBASE
Pub Med and The Cochrane Library were searched from the time databases were built until January 2015 to identify the randomized controlled clinical studies on Yiqi Fumai Injection( lyophilization) combined with conventional western medicine to treat heart failure. The unified forms were used to collect information such as patients’ general data
intervention measure and observational index. The bias-risk assessment tools provided by Cochrane collaboration network were applied to make methodological quality assessment for the including studies. Rev Man 5. 2. 6 was used for Meta analysis on clinical comprehensive effects
cardiac functional grading
left ventricular ejection fraction
left ventricular end-diastolic diameter and amino-terminal pro-brain natriuretic peptide of patients. Results Eighteen articles were indentified
with 1939 patients involved in. The quality of literature was poor. Results of meta analysis showed that combined with Yiqi Fumai Injection( lyophilization) into the treatment of chronic heart failure may improve clinical comprehensive effects [OR = 3. 63
95% CI( 2. 22
5. 93)
P < 0. 001]
improve cardiac function[OR = 1. 98
95% CI( 1. 48
2. 65)
P < 0. 001]
increase left ventricular ejection fraction [WMD = 4. 35
95%CI( 3. 32
5. 38)
P < 0. 001]
lower left ventricular end-diastolic diameter [WMD =- 2. 59
95% CI(- 4. 97
- 0. 21)
P < 0. 03 ]
and reduce amino-terminal pro-brain natriuretic peptide [WMD =- 298. 41
95% CI(- 453. 86
- 142. 97)
P0. 0002). Conclusion Based on those indentified studies
Yiqi Fumai Injection( lyophilization) combined with conventional western medicine to treat chronic heart failure may further improve symptoms and cardiac function