WANG Mancai, HOU Xiaoxiang, MA Tianlong, et al. Meta Analysis of Houpo Paiqi Mixture (厚朴排气合剂) in Treating Post-operative Gastrointestinal Motility Disorder[J]. Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine2016, 57(9): 747-752.
WANG Mancai, HOU Xiaoxiang, MA Tianlong, et al. Meta Analysis of Houpo Paiqi Mixture (厚朴排气合剂) in Treating Post-operative Gastrointestinal Motility Disorder[J]. Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine2016, 57(9): 747-752.DOI: 10.13288/j.11-2166/r.2016.09.009.
采用Stata 12软件和Rev Man 5.3软件对主要结局指标术后肛门首次排气时间及次要结局指标术后首次排便时间、肠鸣音恢复时间进行Meta分析。结果共纳入符合标准的文献16篇
总样本量为2247例。仅有4篇文献报道了具体的随机分配方法。Meta分析结果显示
厚朴排气合剂对腹部非胃肠吻合术、妇科手术、剖宫产术等各类术后胃肠动力障碍均具有明确的疗效
能显著缩短术后首次排气时间(WMD=-11.82
95%CI:-14.80
-
8.84
P
<
0.01;WMD=-18.19
95%CI:-27.58
-
8.79
P
<
0.01;WMD=-10.95
95%CI:-16.22
-
5.69
P
<
0.01)、排便时间(WMD=-8.58
95%CI:-15.95
-
1.21
P=0.02;WMD=-28.4
95%CI:-35.4
-
20.68
P
<
0.01;WMD=-15.74
95%CI:-30.29
-
1.20
P=0.03)及肠鸣音恢复时间(WMD=-3.52
95%CI:-5.08
-
1.96
P
<
0.01;WMD=-8.68
95%CI:-10.37
-
6.99
P
<
0.01;WMD=-9.58
95%CI:-14.16
-
5.01
P
<
0.01)
未见明显的药物不良反应。结论厚朴排气合剂用于术后胃肠动力障碍的治疗效果明确
短期使用未发现明显的药物不良反应。
Abstract
Objective To evaluate the effect and safety of Houpo Paiqi Mixture( 厚朴排气合剂) treating postoperative gastrointestinal motility disorders. Methods Reviewed all published literature from Pub Med
EMBASE
Cochrane Library
Web of Knowledge
Chinese Science Citation Database
China National Knowledge Infrastructure
VIP Data and Wan Fang Data
from the establishment of the databases to March of 2015. The randomized controlled trials of Houpo Paiqi Mixture treating types of disorders of gastrointestinal motility after operation were included. Two reviewers screened the papers
extracted data and evaluated papers quality independently. Made Meta analysis on the primary outcome index( the first flatus time after operation) and the secondary outcome indexes( the first defecation time after operation and the recovery time of borborygmus) adopting the software of Stata 12 and Rev Man 5. 3.Results Sixteen papers accorded with standard were included. The total sample size was 2247 cases. Only 4 papers recorded concrete random allocation methods. Meta analysis results showed that Houpo Paiqi Mixture was effective on disorders of gastrointestinal motility after operations
such as abdominal non gastrointestinal anastomosis
gynecologic operations
cesarean sections. It could shorten the first flatus time after operation( WMD =- 11. 82
95% CI:- 14. 80
-
8. 84
P
<
0. 01; WMD =- 18. 19
95% CI:- 27. 58
-
8. 79
P
<
0. 01; WMD =- 10. 95
95%CI:- 16. 22
-
5. 69
P
<
0. 01)
the first defecation time( WMD =- 8. 58
95% CI:- 15. 95
-
1. 21
P =0. 02; WMD =- 28. 4
95% CI:- 35. 4
-
20. 68
P
<
0. 01; WMD =- 15. 74
95% CI:- 30. 29
-
1. 20
P = 0. 03) and the recovery time of borborygmus( WMD =- 3. 52
95% CI:- 5. 08
-
1. 96
P
<
0. 01; WMD =- 8. 68
95% CI:- 10. 37
-
6. 99
P
<
0. 01; WMD =- 9. 58
95% CI:- 14. 16
-
5. 01
P
<
0. 01). No obvious drug adverse reaction. Conclusion Houpo Paiqi Mixture was effective in treating disorders of gastrointestinal motility after operation. There was no obvious drug adverse reaction during short-term application.