WANG Lei, WANG Shouchuan. Meta-analysis of Therapeutic Effect of Reduning Injection(热毒宁注射液) in Treating Children with HandFoot-and-Mouth Disease[J]. Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine2016, 57(21): 1838-1841.
WANG Lei, WANG Shouchuan. Meta-analysis of Therapeutic Effect of Reduning Injection(热毒宁注射液) in Treating Children with HandFoot-and-Mouth Disease[J]. Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine2016, 57(21): 1838-1841.DOI: 10.13288/j.11-2166/r.2016.21.010.
Objective To evaluate the therapeutic effect of Reduning Injection( 热毒宁注射液) in treating children with hand-foot-and-mouth disease( HFMD). Methods Retrieved China Journal Full-text Database
VIP Chinese scientific journals database
Wanfang database
Chinese Master Theses Full-text Database
and selected the randomized controlled trials about Reduning Injection in the treatment of children with HFMD. The retrieval time for each database is from establishing time of each database to December 2015. Using the modified Jadad scale to evaluate the quality of literature
the researchers conducted meta-analysis of the fever clearance time
skin rash subsiding time
oral herpes regression time
clinical efficiency for all the selected modern literature. Results A total of 7literatures were included with Jadad scores more than or equal to 3 points. When treating HFMD
Reduning Injection is better than ribavirin in fever clearance time [WMD =- 1. 38
95% CI(- 1. 83
- 0. 93)
Z = 6. 04
P <0. 001]
skin rash subsiding time [WMD =- 1. 83
95% CI(- 2. 32
- 1. 34)
Z = 7. 35
P < 0. 001 ]
oral herpes regression time [WMD =- 2. 06
95% CI(- 2. 18
- 1. 93
Z = 31. 89
P < 0. 001] and clinical efficiency [RR = 1. 23
95% CI( 1. 15
1. 33)
P < 0. 001]. There was no obvious or serious adverse reaction
and there was low possibility of publication bias. Conclusion Reduning Injection is superior to ribavirin in clinical symptom improvement and clinical efficiency of children HFMD.