1. 广州中医药大学针灸康复临床医学院
2. 广州中医药大学第一附属医院
纸质出版:2017
移动端阅览
[1]李克嵩,庄礼兴,贺君,张宾,罗晓舟,孙一涵,王明华.针灸治疗视神经萎缩累积Meta分析[J].中医杂志,2017,58(06):482-488.
LI Kesong, ZHUANG Lixing, HE Jun, et al. Cumulative Meta-analysis of Acupuncture Treating Optic Atrophy[J]. Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine2017, 58(6): 482-488.
[1]李克嵩,庄礼兴,贺君,张宾,罗晓舟,孙一涵,王明华.针灸治疗视神经萎缩累积Meta分析[J].中医杂志,2017,58(06):482-488. DOI: 10.13288/j.11-2166/r.2017.06.009.
LI Kesong, ZHUANG Lixing, HE Jun, et al. Cumulative Meta-analysis of Acupuncture Treating Optic Atrophy[J]. Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine2017, 58(6): 482-488. DOI: 10.13288/j.11-2166/r.2017.06.009.
目的基于累积Meta分析探索针灸治疗视神经萎缩的有效性和可能存在的优势。方法检索Cochrane Library、Pub Med、EMbase、AMED、Nature、Science online、World Sci Net、中国生物医学文献光盘数据库(CBM)、中国期刊全文数据库(CNKI)、万方资源数据库等
纳入针灸或针灸结合药物与药物比较治疗视神经萎缩的随机对照试验和临床对照试验
对纳入文献的研究方法学进行质量评价和偏倚风险评估
制定资料提取表并提取资料
对其主要结局指标总有效率和次要结局指标视力、视野(包括平均光敏感度及平均缺损)、图形视觉诱发电位P100振幅及潜伏时间进行累积Meta分析并对其结果的时间趋势进行检验。结果共纳入16项研究
累计样本量1369例。所纳入文献方法学质量普遍较低
纳入研究同质性高
发表偏倚风险较小。除在改善患者图形视觉诱发电位P100振幅方面治疗组和对照组差异不具有统计学意义[SMD=0.11
95%CI(-0.20
0.43)
Z=0.69
P=0.49]外
其余各项指标治疗组疗效均优于对照组
包括治疗组总有效率优于对照组
[RR=0.39
95%CI(0.31
0.47)]
改善患者视力优于对照组[SMD=0.67
95%CI(0.38
0.96)]
改善患者视野平均光敏感度优于对照组[SMD=0.55
95%CI(0.32
0.77)]
改善患者视野平均缺损度优于对照组[SMD=-0.42
95%CI(-0.65
-0.19)]
改善患者图形视觉诱发电位P100潜伏时间优于对照组[SMD=-0.38
95%CI(-0.63
-0.14)]
以上结果均具有统计学意义(P<0.05)。时间趋势检验方面
除视野两项指标及P100潜伏时间在时间的变化中不存在易变性外
其余各项指标检验结果均提示其结果尚未趋于稳定。结论针灸或针灸联合药物治疗视神经萎缩在改善患者视力、视野及总有效率方面优于药物疗法
但确切结论仍需高质量大样本多中心的随机对照试验验证。
Objective To explore the effect and possible advantages of acupuncture in treating optic atrophy based on cumulative Meta-analysis.Methods Cochrane Library
Pub Med
EMbase( Excerpta Medica database)
AMED
Nature
Science Online
World Sci Net
Chinese Biomedical Literature Database Disc( CBM)
China national knowledge infrastructure( CNKI) and Wanfang Data
etc.were searched.Randomized controlled trials and clinical controlled trials of comparing acupuncture or acupuncture & medicine with medicine in treating optic atrophy were included.Quality assessment and bias risk assessment were conducted on the research methodology of included papers.Data collection forms were made and data were collected.Cumulative Meta-analysis was performed on the main outcome index( total effective rate) and second outcome indexes: visual acuity
visual field( including average light sensitivity and mean defect)
pattern visual evoked potential P100 amplitude and latent time.The time trend of the results was examined.Results Sixteen researches were included
with cumulative sample size of 1369.Methodological quality of included papers was generally low.Included papers were of high homogeneity
with low publication bias risk.There was no significant difference in improving patients’ pattern visual evoked potential P100 amplitude between the treatment group and the control group [SMD = 0.11
95% CI(-0.20
0.43)
Z = 0.69
P = 0.49].Except that
other indexes in the treatment group were all superior to those in the control group.The total effective rate in the treatment group was superior to that in the control group [RR = 0.39
95% CI( 0.31
0.47) ].As for improving patients’ visual acuity
the treatment group was superior to the control group [SMD = 0.67
95% CI( 0.38
0.96) ].As for improving patients’ visual field average light sensitivity
the treatment group was superior[SMD = 0.55
95% CI( 0.32
0.77) ].As for improving patients’ visual field mean defect
the treatment group was superior [SMD =-0.42
95% CI(-0.65
-0.19) ].As for improving patients’ pattern visual evoked potential P100 latent time
the treatment group was superior [SMD =-0.38
95% CI(-0.63
-0.14) ].The differences of those results were significant( P < 0.05).As for time trend examination
two indexes of visual field and P100 latent time had no volatility in time changes
while the examination results of other indexes showed that the results were not stable yet.Conclusion Acupuncture or acupuncture & medicine treatment for optic atrophy is superior to medicine treatment in the aspects of improving patients’ visual acuity
visual field and total effective rate.However
the exact conclusion needs to be proved by high-quality
large-sample and multi-center randomized controlled trials.
0
浏览量
822
下载量
1
CSCD
关联资源
相关文章
相关作者
相关机构
京公网安备11010102007558号